Crisis Management or Succession Planning

Episode 2 • September 25, 2026 • 00:21:28
Crisis Management or Succession Planning
Passing the Mantle
Crisis Management or Succession Planning

Sep 25 2026 | 00:21:28

/

Hosted By

Dr Peter Frost, PhD

Show Notes

Why do so many organizations scramble to find a new leader only after someone leaves? In Episode 2 of Passing the Mantle, Peter Frost explores the difference between crisis management and intentional succession planning—and asks a challenging question: Where do you find your leaders?

Drawing on more than 30 years of leadership experience and the biblical relationship between Moses and Joshua, Peter looks at when hiring from outside makes sense, what it may reveal when no one inside is ready, and how leaders can recognize and develop potential successors. The episode’s central lesson: succession planning is not a last-minute replacement. It is the patient, relational work of bringing emerging leaders close, giving them responsibility, supporting them, and preparing them over time.

Who are the “Joshuas” in your church, ministry, business, or team? Learn how to start noticing and developing them before a leadership crisis arrives.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

Let me ask you a question that might make you a little uncomfortable. Take an honest look at your organization—your church, your ministry, your business, your team. Where do you find your leaders? I mean, really. When you need someone to step into a significant role, where do you look? Do you look inside—at the people who have been laboring alongside you, growing, developing, waiting? Or do you immediately post a job listing and start sorting through resumes from strangers? Here's what I have discovered in over thirty years of leadership experience between the Navy, local church, mission field, and in business: the answer to that question reveals more about your leadership health than almost anything else. And if your honest answer is, "Well, we hire them from outside," I want you to stay with me. Because sometimes that's exactly right. And sometimes it's a symptom of something we've neglected for far too long. Welcome back to the podcast. I'm Peter Frost, and this is Episode Two of our series on succession planning through intentional leadership development. If you joined us for Episode One, you know we're working through the conviction that passing the mantle—raising up the next generation of leaders—is not optional. It's not something we squeeze in when we have time. It's woven into the very fabric of discipleship itself. My doctoral work focused on this exact topic, specifically designing strategies for succession planning through intentional leadership development for the Summer Institute of Linguistics in Papua New Guinea—an organization I served with for years. And what I found in the research, and more importantly, what I've experienced on the field and in Scripture, is that most organizations don't have a succession problem. They have a development problem. Today we're tackling a question that sits at the crossroads of crisis and intentionality: Crisis Management or Succession Planning—Where Do We Find Our Leaders? Let's dig in. Before we get to Scripture, I want you to do something with me. I want you to perform an honest audit of your leadership pipeline. Ask yourself: Over the past five years, when we've had a key leadership vacancy, where did our replacement come from? Did we promote from within? Did we bring someone in from outside? Did we leave the position vacant for months while we searched? Now here's the harder question: If we had to fill a critical leadership role tomorrow—say, our executive director retired unexpectedly, or our lead pastor was called away, or our department head resigned—who would step in? Do you have a name? Do you have two names? If you don't, you're not alone. But that absence—that empty bench—that's what we're here to address. Here's where I want to be really careful, because I don't want to create a false dichotomy. Hiring from outside is not inherently wrong. In fact, sometimes it's the wisest, most Spirit-led decision you can make. So let's talk about when it's good, when it's wrong, and—this is the tricky one—when it's wrong but we feel like we have no choice. There are legitimate, healthy reasons to bring leaders in from outside your organization. Let me give you two. First: Your organization is experiencing tremendous growth, and you genuinely lack competent leaders to fill the new roles that growth demands. If keeping your current people in their current positions is what allows the mission to keep moving forward, then importing the right leaders from outside is not a failure—it's a strategic necessity. But notice what I said: the right leaders. Not just warm bodies. Not just impressive resumes. Leaders whose values match your organization's values. Because a leader who doesn't share your core convictions will eventually pull your organization in a direction you never intended to go. Second: Your organization has a toxic culture or is in decline, and you need leaders who can come in and change that culture to match the vision. Sometimes the people inside an organization are so shaped by the dysfunction that they can't see it, much less fix it. Bringing in leaders with experience in growth and transformation—leaders who again match your values—can be the intervention that saves the mission. I've seen this happen. It's real. It's biblical. Moses brought in Jethro's wisdom. Paul brought in Timothy. Sometimes the outsider brings the clarity the insider cannot. So yes—there are good reasons. But let's talk about the reasons that aren't so good. Here's the first wrong reason, and it's the one that breaks my heart: You hire from outside because no one inside is capable, competent, and has the character to move up. Or—and this is the painful part—no one inside wants to be a leader. I've sat in rooms where this conversation happened. "We have to bring someone in," they say. "There's no one here ready." And I want to ask: Why not? What have we been doing for the past five years? Ten years? If we knew this moment was coming—and we always know it's coming, because leaders eventually leave, retire, or are called elsewhere—why didn't we prepare someone? That's the difference between crisis management and succession planning. Crisis management waits until the need is urgent and then scrambles. Succession planning sees the need coming and prepares in advance. When we say, "We have to hire from outside because no one is ready," what we're often really saying is, "We didn't do the work of development." Then there are the reasons that aren't even about capacity. They're about our own preferences and blind spots. You know the first one: "Their resume is awesome." This person went to the right schools, worked at the right organizations, has the right credentials. And look—resumes matter. Experience matters. But here's what a resume cannot tell you: Does this person share your values? Will they love your people? Will they understand your culture? Will they stay when things get hard? I've seen brilliant leaders with flawless resumes crash and burn because they couldn't connect with the team, couldn't adapt to the culture, couldn't embrace the mission as their own. Sometimes the most impressive candidate is the biggest culture mismatch. And then there's this one: "They graduated from a certain school." Look, I value theological education. I have a doctorate. But alumni status is not the same as cultural fit. Shared institutional heritage is not the same as shared vision. We can't confuse pedigree with calling. What does the Bible say? Let me be careful here. The Bible is not primarily a leadership manual. It is God's redemptive story—the account of how God is reconciling a broken creation to Himself through Jesus Christ. We don't read Scripture looking for corporate best practices. We read it looking for the heart of God. But here's what we find as we read: God's plan for leadership development is embedded within His plan for making disciples. There's no separation. Leadership development is discipleship with a specific focus. Consider spiritual gifting. In Romans 12, verses 3 through 8, Paul teaches that we each have gifts according to the grace given to us. And among those gifts, Paul lists leadership—sometimes translated administration or governance. It's a gift from God, distributed by the Holy Spirit. And Paul's instruction is to use it with diligence. Leaders aren't just made by human effort—they're given by God. Peter echoes this in 1 Peter 4:10: "Just as each one has received a gift, use it to serve others, as good stewards of the varied grace of God." Leadership is a gift. Leadership is also a talent. It's a stewardship. And here's the implication for succession planning: if God gives leadership gifts and talents to people within the body, then our job is not to manufacture leaders from nothing—it's to identify the gifts and talents God has already placed among us and cultivate them. And that takes time. Leaders are developed through time. Through relationship. Through mentorship. Through serving. There's no shortcut. Which brings us to an incredible case study in Scripture. Let me frame the question that now drives us: Who is a potential leader for our organization? What should we be looking for? How does the Bible help me in succession planning? Because here's the challenge—and this is where I want you to feel the weight of it—how do you identify someone before they've been tested? How do you spot the leader in the crowd before their résumé is written? Let's look at Moses and Joshua. Turn with me to Exodus chapter 17. This is the first time Joshua appears in Scripture. And I mean that literally—before this moment, Joshua is mentioned nowhere. He has no backstory. No genealogy is given for him here. No explanation of where he came from or how he acquired his skills. He simply appears. Let me read the passage. Exodus 17, verses 9 and 10: "Moses said to Joshua, 'Select some men for us and go fight against Amalek. Tomorrow I will stand on the hilltop with God's staff in my hand.' Joshua did as Moses had told him, and fought against Amalek, while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill." Now—if you know the Old Testament story, you know what happens next. You know that Joshua becomes the successor to Moses. You know he leads Israel into the Promised Land. You know he's one of the great figures of the faith. But here's what you need to see: at the moment he's introduced, we don't know any of that. And here's something obvious that's easy to miss. Why did Moses pick Joshua? We don't know. The text doesn't tell us. There's no account of Moses evaluating candidates. No interview. No committee. Joshua simply appears as the man Moses trusted to lead the battle. That's worth sitting with. Leaders sometimes arise from unexpected places. People with leadership qualities—even when those qualities haven't been documented or credentialed—will be noticed by those who are seeking God's direction. Segment Eight: What the Scholars Say (17:30–22:00) Now, I've spent years researching this, and I want to share what I found. But I also want to credit the scholars who have helped shape my understanding. A review of commentaries on Exodus by Stuart, on Numbers by Ashley, and on Deuteronomy by Merrill provides insight into the development of Joshua as the successor to Moses. Joshua's role as Moses' assistant, his faith in God, and previous experience in various leadership positions made Joshua the logical choice to succeed Moses. Now, you might be thinking—"Wait, you just said we don't know his backstory." And that's true. As I put it in Passing the Mantle, "Scripture does not provide us with Joshua's background. We do not know how he learned his military skills, he simply appears ready to lead Israel in its first battle and victory." But notice: this first appearance in Exodus 17 isn't the whole story. What we see here is the beginning of a decades-long development process. Fountain, writing in 2004, suggests that Joshua, Samuel, and Elisha were each developed over a couple of decades to be the successor for Moses, Eli, and Elijah, respectively. Joshua spent forty years being developed as Moses' successor. Think about that. Forty years. Four decades of preparation before the mantle passed. Fountain demonstrates that Joshua, Elisha, and Samuel spent their formative years serving Moses, Elijah, and Eli. The development of these leaders was not rushed. It was patient, intentional, and relational. Now here's something I want you to sit with, because it reframes everything. In Passing the Mantle I point out that Joshua's role as Moses's assistant is not like the modern role of an assistant to a leader. Joshua was not "second in command." Joshua represents the next generation of leadership for Israel. He is about thirty-five years younger than Moses. Throughout the remaining years of wilderness wandering, Joshua was probably near Moses, observing how Moses handled situations, and watching how Moses communicated with the LORD. That's the shape of it. Not a title. Nearness, over years. The Dictionary of Biblical Imagery comments on Moses: "Perhaps no other person in the Bible so graphically embodies the role and character of the leader as Moses." And they note that wherever Moses goes, Joshua follows. Joshua is the shadow. He is present. He is learning. He is being shaped. Now here's what I find so fascinating about Exodus 17. This passage foreshadows the relationship between Moses and Joshua. Moses delegated the responsibility of selecting who would fight. Joshua selected the men without consulting Moses. Moses did not micromanage Joshua during the battle, but he supported Joshua during the battle. Do you see the leadership development happening here? Moses gave Joshua real responsibility. He didn't hover. He didn't second-guess. He let Joshua lead. But he also didn't abandon him. Moses stood on the hilltop, holding up the staff, interceding for the battle. Supporting without micromanaging. And Scripture still doesn't provide us with Joshua's background. He simply appears—ready to lead Israel in its first battle and victory. Now, this is important: The modern reader has the advantage of knowing the end of the story when reading Exodus 17. We know Joshua becomes the successor. But if we were to ignore what is to come and focus on just Exodus 17, we note something significant: Leaders arise from unexpected places. And we observe that people with leadership qualities will be noticed by those seeking God's direction. That's the key. Moses was seeking God's direction. And in seeking, he noticed Joshua. And the development was long. Years later, in Numbers 27, Moses commissions Joshua before the priest Eleazar and the whole community. Part of Moses's authority was immediately transferred to Joshua to ensure a smooth transition. It wasn't a private handoff—it was public, witnessed, and ordered. Then Deuteronomy 34:9 says, "Now Joshua the son of Nun was filled with the spirit of wisdom, for Moses had laid his hands on him; the sons of Israel listened to him and did as the LORD had commanded Moses." Filled. Prepared. Received. That's what patient, intentional development produces. And here's the summary I keep coming back to—of all the leader-successor models examined in Passing the Mantle, the Moses-Joshua relationship lasted the longest. So let me bring this home. What I want you to hear today is this central distinction: Crisis replacement is not succession planning. When a leader leaves and we scramble to find "the next man up"—that's crisis management. And crisis management has its place. Organizations need contingency plans. Sometimes a crisis does move someone into a role, and by God's grace, they rise to the occasion. But that's not the same as succession planning. Succession planning is the long-term cultivation of a person over years. It's what Moses did with Joshua. It's what Elijah would later do with Elisha. It's what Eli did—imperfectly—with Samuel. It's intentional. It's patient. It's relational. It's the active, daily work of bringing someone alongside you, giving them responsibility, letting them lead, supporting them while they lead, and watching to see how God develops them. Organizations that focus on succession planning through intentional leadership development—they build deep bench strength. They don't wait until the crisis comes. They prepare in advance. Here's your takeaway for this week: Look around your organization. Look around your church, your ministry, your team. Who are the Joshuas? Who is the person quietly serving, faithfully present, showing glimpses of leadership that others might overlook? Are you noticing them? Are you bringing them close? Are you giving them opportunity? And are you—right now—doing the long, slow, unglamorous work of developing them? Not because a crisis is coming, but because faithfulness demands it. Leaders arise from unexpected places. But they don't develop by accident. Someone has to notice. Someone has to invest. Someone has to pass the mantle. Next time, we're going back to the mountain. The story of Moses and Joshua isn't finished—it's just getting started. We'll pick up in Exodus 24, where Moses arises with his assistant Joshua and goes up the mountain of God, telling the elders to wait for them until they return. Moses goes higher. Joshua goes halfway. And down in the camp, well—there's a party. A golden calf, and a people already drifting. Here's what gets me: Joshua is halfway up the mountain. And that halfway position kept him from participating in the Golden Calf incident. From his reaction in Exodus 32:17—when he hears the shouting and tells Moses, "There is a sound of war in the camp"—we could deduce that Joshua spent the entire time on the mountain with Moses. He was close enough to be protected. Close enough to be shaped. Close enough to miss the party. So next time we'll ask: what does it look like to keep your successor close—close enough that they're formed by your presence with God, and close enough to be spared the chaos below? Until then—look for the Joshuas. And be faithful in the slow work of development. God bless you.

Other Episodes

Episode 3

September 25, 2026 • 00:22:14
Episode Cover

Halfway There

How do you keep going when leadership development feels like a long journey—and you can’t see how far you’ve come or how much farther...

Listen

Episode 4

October 23, 2026 • 00:26:50
Episode Cover

Time in the Tent

In Episode 4 of Passing the Mantle, Dr. Peter Frost explores how Moses prepared Joshua for leadership through years of faithful service—and one seemingly...

Listen

Episode 5

October 30, 2026 • 00:22:20
Episode Cover

Episode 5 - The Lone Dissenter

What does it mean to stand by your convictions when everyone around you disagrees? In this episode of Passing the Mantle, Peter Frost reflects...

Listen