Episode Transcript
Have you ever been the only one in the room who saw things differently?
Maybe you were in a meeting where everyone nodded in agreement, and you knew — you knew — that something was wrong. Or perhaps you were the single voice saying, "Wait. Let's think about this. Let's pray about this." And in that moment, you felt the weight of standing alone.
Today, we're going to talk about what it means to be the lone dissenter — to stand out because you're different — and to do it not out of stubbornness, but out of conviction.
[MUSIC FADES]
STANDING OUT BECAUSE I WAS DIFFERENT:
I want to begin with a story from my own life. Some of you have heard me talk about my Navy years, and today I want to take you back to my second duty station. I was stationed at Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe — also known as SHAPE — in Casteau, Belgium.
Now, SHAPE was an interesting assignment. It was a multinational environment, which meant I was working alongside people from all across NATO. But there were still times when the Navy folks would gather together — Navy-only events, quarterly meetings, that sort of thing. And at those gatherings, after the meeting, we could hang out. A lot of my fellow Sailors would imbibe beer.
[PAUSE]
I didn't drink beer with everyone else. Not because I couldn't. Not because I was trying to make a statement. I simply believed — as a young Christian — that the Lord did not want me to drink during working hours. Even though I had permission, even though it was perfectly acceptable in that culture, I made the decision to drink a Coke instead of a beer.
And let me tell you — I stood out. When you're the only one at the table with a soft drink, people notice. For a while, I was the only Enlisted Sailor who didn't drink during our quarterly meetings.
[PAUSE]
But then Randy was assigned to SHAPE. And Randy — Randy didn't drink either. And suddenly, there were two of us. Two Sailors, sitting there with our Cokes, standing out together. We stood out. We stood out because we believed the Lord did not want us to drink during working hours, even if we had permission. We stood out because of our convictions.
[PAUSE]
Now, here's what I want you to hear in that story: I was not trying to be different. I was not trying to be difficult. I was simply trying to be faithful. But faithfulness, brothers and sisters, often makes you stand out. It often makes you the lone dissenter. And that is not always comfortable.
NOT THE LAST TIME:
That experience at SHAPE was not the last time I found myself disagreeing with others. In fact, as I matured in my faith, I discovered that standing on conviction would become a recurring theme in my life and ministry.
I was a young Christian when I made that decision to drink Coke instead of beer. I was still figuring out what it meant to follow Jesus. But as the years went on, and as I grew in my understanding of Scripture and leadership, I would find myself in situations where I had to speak up — where I had to offer a different perspective.
One example that comes to mind is a Deacon's meeting. We were discussing the future of our church, and I suggested something that I thought was quite reasonable. I suggested that we survey our neighborhood — actually go out and see what the community around us looked like. What were the needs? Who was living there? What had changed?
[PAUSE]
One of the deacons responded, "We've done that before, and it didn't help."
But here's the thing — "before" was twenty years earlier. Twenty years! The neighborhood had changed dramatically in two decades. The people were different. The needs were different. And yet, because it had been tried once, and because it hadn't produced the results they wanted, the suggestion was dismissed.
I was the lone dissenter in that room.
[PAUSE]
And then there's my dissertation work. If you've been listening to this podcast, you know that my doctoral research was driven by a very specific belief: the belief that we have people capable of leading if they are properly developed. I was convinced — and I remain convinced — that the church has failed to invest in leadership development the way we should.
But I was not alone in that belief — yet I was in the minority. I was in the minority in Administration. Not everyone shared my urgency. Not everyone saw the same need. And so, once again, I found myself standing on conviction, offering a perspective that others did not necessarily share.
[PAUSE]
Now, I share these stories not to pat myself on the back. I share them because I suspect many of you know exactly what I'm talking about. You've been the voice of dissent. You've been the one who saw things differently. And maybe you've wondered, "Am I crazy? Am I the only one who sees this?"
Today, I want to encourage you. Because you are not alone in your calling to stand on conviction.
THE VOICES OF REASON:
Today we are going to look at a very familiar passage of Scripture — Numbers chapters 13 and 14. This is one of the most powerful stories of dissenting faith in the entire Bible. It's the story of the twelve spies, the report they brought back, and the courage of two men — Caleb and Joshua — who dared to stand alone.
This is a long passage, so I want to hit the highlights — but I do want you to hear the actual text. So let's set the scene.
The Israelites are on the edge of the Promised Land. They've been wandering in the wilderness, and now God tells Moses to send men to spy out the land of Canaan. But look carefully at who is chosen.
[READ SCRIPTURE — Numbers 13:3, CSB]
"Moses sent them from the Wilderness of Paran at the Lord's command. All the men were leaders in Israel." — Numbers 13:3 (CSB)
Notice that all of the men were leaders of their tribes. These weren't random scouts. These were the men who had recognition and authority among the people. Interestingly, Levi is not included — but Joseph's two sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, are included. This was a careful selection, because these were the leaders who would eventually lead the conquest.
And if we look closely at verse 8 and verse 16, we see something remarkable.
[READ SCRIPTURE — Numbers 13:8 and 16, CSB]
"Hoshea son of Nun from the tribe of Ephraim ... These were the names of the men Moses sent to scout out the land, and Moses renamed Hoshea son of Nun, Joshua." — Numbers 13:8, 16 (CSB)
Joshua gets a name change. He was originally called Hoshea, but Moses renamed him Joshua — and that name means "The LORD saves." Even before Joshua enters the Promised Land, God is already marking him out as a man of faith, a man whose very name declares the salvation of the Lord.
Now, let's move to the report.
[READ SCRIPTURE — Numbers 13:26–14:10, CSB]
Numbers 13:26–33 (CSB): The men went back to Moses, Aaron, and the entire Israelite community in the Wilderness of Paran at Kadesh. They brought back a report for them and the whole community, and they showed them the fruit of the land. They reported to Moses: "We went into the land where you sent us. Indeed it is flowing with milk and honey, and here is some of its fruit. However, the people living in the land are strong, and the cities are large and fortified. We also saw the descendants of Anak there. The Amalekites are living in the land of the Negev; the Hittites, Jebusites, and Amorites live in the hill country; and the Canaanites live by the sea and along the Jordan."
Then Caleb quieted the people in the presence of Moses and said, "We must go up and take possession of the land because we can certainly conquer it!"
But the men who had gone up with him responded, "We can't go up against the people because they are stronger than we are!" So they gave a negative report to the Israelites about the land they had scouted: "The land we passed through to explore is one that devours its inhabitants, and all the people we saw in it are men of great size. We even saw the Nephilim there." (The offspring of Anak were descended from the Nephilim.) "To ourselves we seemed like grasshoppers, and we must have seemed the same to them."
Numbers 14:1–10 (CSB): Then the whole community broke into loud cries, and the people wept that night. All the Israelites complained about Moses and Aaron, and the whole community told them, "If only we had died in the land of Egypt, or if only we had died in this wilderness! Why is the Lord bringing us into this land to die by the sword? Our wives and little children will become plunder. Wouldn't it be better for us to go back to Egypt?" So they said to one another, "Let's appoint a leader and go back to Egypt."
Then Moses and Aaron fell down with their faces to the ground in front of the whole assembly of the Israelite community. Joshua son of Nun and Caleb son of Jephunneh, who were among those who scouted out the land, tore their clothes and said to the entire Israelite community: "The land we passed through and explored is an extremely good land. If the Lord is pleased with us, He will bring us into this land, a land flowing with milk and honey, and give it to us. Only don't rebel against the Lord, and don't be afraid of the people of the land, for we will devour them. Their protection has been removed from them, and the Lord is with us. Don't be afraid of them!"
While the whole community threatened to stone them, the glory of the Lord appeared to all the Israelites at the tent of meeting.
Here's what happened. The spies came back after forty days of exploring the land. And initially, the report was positive. The land was flowing with milk and honey. It was everything God had promised.
But then — then came the fear.
Ten of the spies began to describe the inhabitants of the land as giants. They described themselves as grasshoppers. They said, "We can't go up against these people. They're too strong. The cities are fortified. We'll be destroyed."
And the people — the congregation of Israel — they began to weep. They began to complain. They said, "Why did God bring us out here to die by the sword? Our wives and children will be taken captive. Let's choose a new leader and go back to Egypt."
[PAUSE]
You can feel the rebellion in their voices, can't you? They were ready to turn their backs on the promise of God.
STANDING ON FAITH:
But then — then Caleb and Joshua stood up.
Caleb had already spoken earlier. He had said, "We must go up and take possession of the land because we can certainly conquer it!" And now, as the people descended into panic and rebellion, Joshua joined Caleb. They tore their clothes in grief — an act of mourning over the faithlessness they were witnessing.
And listen to what they said. They said, "The land we passed through and explored is an extremely good land. If the Lord is pleased with us, He will bring us into this land, a land flowing with milk and honey, and give it to us. Only don't rebel against the Lord, and don't be afraid of the people of the land, for we will devour them. Their protection has been removed from them, and the Lord is with us. Don't be afraid of them!"
[PAUSE]
These two men — Caleb and Joshua — they stood alone. The entire congregation was ready to stone them. The murmurings, the fear, the rebellion — it was all directed against them. But they stood on their faith. They believed that God was able to do what He had promised.
And here's the key: while Caleb did most of the speaking in Numbers chapter 13, both Caleb and Joshua exhorted the people in chapter 14. Joshua's words reaffirmed what Caleb had said. They were not competing voices. They were united voices — two men standing together on the same conviction.
[PAUSE]
Now, I want to pause and reflect on this for a moment, because this is so important. Caleb is the one who speaks first. He is the one who says, "We must go up and take possession of the land." But Joshua — Joshua stands with him. Joshua agrees. Joshua affirms.
Sometimes standing alone doesn't mean standing by yourself. Sometimes it means standing with one other person who shares your conviction. And that can make all the difference in the world.
ANALYSIS FROM THE DISSERTATION:
Now, in my dissertation and in my book, "Passing the Mantle," I identified four biblical examples of succession planning through intentional leadership development. These four models are:
First, Moses and Joshua. Second, Elijah and Elisha. Third, Jesus and the disciples. And fourth, Paul and Timothy and Titus.
As we look at the Moses-Joshua relationship, I want to draw out some important insights.
First, Joshua's development was not rushed. This is critical. Scholars estimate that Joshua served roughly forty years as Moses's assistant. Forty years! During that time, he served in leadership positions. He was on the mountain with Moses in Exodus chapter 24. He spent time in the Tent of Meeting. He learned from Moses up close, in real-world situations.
That long formation — that patient, intentional development — made Joshua the evident replacement in the eyes of the people. When the time came to appoint a successor, no one was surprised. Joshua was ready.
[PAUSE]
Now, there's an interesting insight from a scholar named Boers. Boers, writing in 2015, states Caleb and Joshua were "the dissenting voice leaders need to have." Boers stresses the importance of listening to the dissenting voices when developing a process for developing new leaders.
Think about that for a moment. In leadership development, we need people who will speak up. We need people who will say, "Wait a minute. Have we considered this? Have we thought about that?" Boers warns against rushing the development of Christian leaders. Development takes time. It takes patience. And it often requires listening to voices that are different from our own.
[PAUSE]
The dissertation research concluded five strategies for leadership development:
First, Clear Plans. Second, Clear Pathways. Third, Clear Pools. Fourth, Character. And fifth, Competencies.
Let me highlight that fourth one — Character. Because here's what I concluded in my research: character matters more than competency for leadership selection. Now, competency is important — don't misunderstand me. We want leaders who are capable and skilled. But when it comes to choosing leaders, character comes first.
The dissertation's character framework includes three things: conviction, courage, and exercising faith.
Conviction. Courage. Faith.
Does that describe anyone in the story we just read? Absolutely. Caleb and Joshua exemplify these three qualities. They had the conviction that God's promise was true. They had the courage to stand before a hostile crowd and speak that truth. And they exercised faith — believing that God would do what He said.
[PAUSE]
My dissertation was driven by the belief that we had people capable of leading if they were properly developed. I was in the minority in Administration, as I mentioned earlier. But that conviction shaped my research, and it shapes this podcast. Because I believe — I truly believe — that God has raised up leaders among His people. They just need to be found, developed, and given opportunities to lead.
ANALYSIS FROM PASSING THE MANTLE:
Now let me turn to my book, "Passing the Mantle," specifically Chapter Three, which is called "Moses and Joshua: Preparation and Transition."
I want to share some insights from that chapter about how Joshua's leadership development worked. References to Joshua occur in three separate sections of Numbers:
First, Numbers 13:1–14:10 — the twelve spies, which we just examined. Second, Numbers 27:12–23 — where Joshua is identified as Moses's successor. Third, Numbers 34:16–17 — where Joshua and Eleazar distribute the land.
[PAUSE]
As we saw earlier, while Caleb did most of the speaking in Numbers chapter 13, both Caleb and Joshua exhorted the people in chapter 14. Joshua and Caleb tore their clothes in remorse over what the other ten spies reported. And Joshua's words reaffirmed what Caleb had said. They were partners in faith.
Next week, we will look at the transition from Moses to Joshua and examine those last two passages in Numbers.
LESSONS LEARNED:
So, what are the lessons we can take from the story of Caleb and Joshua? Let me offer three.
First, do not be afraid to speak the truth about what God can do.
When everyone else was focused on the giants, Caleb and Joshua focused on God. When everyone else was paralyzed by fear, they were energized by faith. They were not naive. They knew the challenges. They saw the same fortified cities and the same powerful enemies. But they believed that God was greater.
[PAUSE]
Here's the lesson: when you know what God is capable of, don't be afraid to say it. Even when it makes you the lone dissenter. Even when the crowd disagrees. Speak the truth about what God can do.
Second, even though Caleb does the speaking, Joshua is agreeing with Caleb.
This is so important. When you stand on conviction, you don't always have to be the one leading the charge. Sometimes, your role is to stand with someone else. To affirm their words. To say, "Yes. I agree. What he said is true."
[PAUSE]
We often celebrate the loudest voice, the boldest speaker. But there is tremendous power in agreement. There is strength in unity. When Joshua stood with Caleb, he doubled the testimony. He confirmed that this was not just one man's opinion. This was a shared conviction.
Third, stand up for what is right.
Caleb and Joshua did not compromise. They did not back down when the crowd threatened to stone them. They stood for what was right, even when it was unpopular. Even when it was dangerous.
[PAUSE]
Brothers and sisters, we live in a time when standing for what is right is becoming increasingly countercultural. The pressure to conform is immense. The temptation to stay silent is real. But if you know what God has said, stand on it. Even if you're alone. Even if you're in the minority. Even if it costs you something. The truth is, you are not alone.
CLOSING:
So, here's my encouragement to you today.
If you've been the lone dissenter — if you've been the one standing on conviction while others shake their heads — take heart. You are in good company. Caleb and Joshua stood alone. And God honored their faith. In fact, God used them to lead an entire generation into the Promised Land.
[PAUSE]
Do not be discouraged when you stand out because you are different. That difference may be exactly what God wants to use. That conviction may be exactly what the next generation needs to see.
Let me pray with you.
[PAUSE]
Father, we thank You for the example of Caleb and Joshua — two men who dared to stand on faith when everyone else was consumed by fear. Lord, give us that kind of courage. When we are tempted to stay silent, give us boldness. When we are tempted to conform, give us conviction. And when we find ourselves standing alone, remind us that You are with us.
Lord, raise up leaders among us who will not be afraid to speak the truth about what You can do. And help us to develop those leaders with patience and intentionality, just as Moses developed Joshua.
We ask this in the name of Your Son, Jesus Christ. Amen.
[MUSIC PLAYING]
TEASER:
Next time on "Passing the Mantle," we're going to watch the succession plan actually unfold. We'll look at Numbers chapter 27, verses 12 through 23, and the passages in Deuteronomy where Moses formally passes the mantle to Joshua. It's one thing to prepare a successor. It's another thing entirely to actually hand off the leadership — to step aside and watch someone else take the reins.
What does that handoff look like? How does Moses prepare the people for the transition? And what can we learn about succession planning from the way it all played out?
Join us next time as we witness the handoff happen. Until then, stand on your convictions.