Episode 7 - But It's Not Christian

Episode 7 • November 13, 2026 • 00:18:15
Episode 7 - But It's Not Christian
Passing the Mantle
Episode 7 - But It's Not Christian

Nov 13 2026 | 00:18:15

/

Hosted By

Dr Peter Frost, PhD

Show Notes

Is succession planning a business idea—or can it serve the work of God? In this episode of Passing the Mantle, Peter Frost, PhD, turns to Exodus 18, where Jethro offers Moses practical counsel: share the work, delegate responsibility, and appoint capable leaders of character.

Drawing on his research and the biblical example of Moses, Peter explores how Christians can thoughtfully use leadership practices from outside the church without treating any system as the gospel. The conversation considers wise counsel, delegation, leadership development, and the danger of believing a leader must do everything alone. It’s an invitation to keep the main thing the main thing—and to prepare others to lead faithfully.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

Welcome back to Passing the Mantle, the podcast where we walk through biblical examples of succession planning and intentional leadership development. I'm Peter Frost, and I'm glad you're with me today. I want to start with a question I get asked a lot. Maybe you've asked it yourself. "Peter, all this talk about succession planning, leadership pipelines, mentoring, delegation — that sounds like a business book. But it's not Christian. Why are we spending time on it?" PAUSE It's a fair question. It deserves a real answer, not a slogan. So today's episode is called "But it's not Christian." And I want to show you, from Scripture, why a good practice or a neutral structure — even one you first encountered in a boardroom — can be placed in a Christian environment and used for the glory of God. Our text is Exodus 18. And the central figure in the second half of that chapter is a man who was not an Israelite, not a prophet, not a priest, and not a king. He was a Midianite priest and a father-in-law. And God used him to change the way Israel was led. The Research Behind This Episode Let me tell you where I'm coming from. During my PhD research, I devoted an entire chapter to examining how organizations demonstrate principles for succession planning through intentional leadership development. And I mean all kinds of organizations. Businesses. Nonprofits. Government agencies. Healthcare systems. Schools. Any other organization you can think of. I wanted to see what they were doing, how they were doing it, and whether any of it held up. I approached that material from my evangelical Christian worldview. That's important, so let me be precise. I did not seek to "baptize" a system. I wasn't trying to sprinkle holy water on a corporate org chart and call it discipleship. But a good practice — or a neutral structure placed in a Christian environment — is worth examining. There's a difference between baptizing a system and examining a practice. A system claims to be the gospel. A practice is just a tool. And tools can be picked up and used by faithful people. Keeping the Main Thing the Main Thing The second thing I learned in that research was just how overwhelming the amount of material was. Millions of articles, books, news stories, blogs, videos, and social media posts about leadership theory, leadership development, succession planning, and the Bible. Millions. I had to remind myself that all the material available was not necessary for my research. I had to narrow my focus to what was relevant. As interested as I am in Authentic Leadership — and I am — I was not researching Authentic Leadership. I needed to focus on strategies for succession planning through intentional leadership development. Keep the main thing the main thing. That's a discipline, isn't it? And it's a discipline that applies to your ministry, your team, your organization. There will always be more good things to read than there is time to read them. The question is whether you'll stay on task. Moses's Father-in-Law Shows Up So let's go to Exodus 18. Moses's father-in-law, Jethro, comes to visit him in the wilderness. He's heard everything God has done for Moses and for Israel, and he brings Moses's wife and sons back to him. Moses goes out to meet him, they exchange greetings, and Moses tells him the whole story — everything the Lord had done. And then the next day, Moses does what he does every day. He sits down to judge the people. I understand Moses wanting to show off for his father-in-law. I have done the same thing. I want to impress him with how well I'm doing at work. I want him to see me handling things, carrying weight, being needed. There's something in us that wants the people we respect to watch us succeed. But Jethro watches Moses, and he sees something Moses can't see. Let's read it. The Scripture Reading Exodus 18:13–26, Christian Standard Bible 13 The next day Moses sat down to judge the people, and they stood around Moses from morning until evening. 14 When Moses's father-in-law saw everything he was doing for them he asked, "What is this you're doing for the people? Why are you alone sitting as judge, while all the people stand around you from morning until evening?" 15 Moses replied to his father-in-law, "Because the people come to me to inquire of God. 16 Whenever they have a dispute, it comes to me, and I make a decision between one man and another. I teach them God's statutes and laws." 17 "What you're doing is not good," Moses's father-in-law said to him. 18 "You will certainly wear out both yourself and these people who are with you, because the task is too heavy for you. You can't do it alone. 19 Now listen to me; I will give you some advice, and God be with you. You be the one to represent the people before God and bring their cases to him. 20 Instruct them about the statutes and laws, and teach them the way to live and what they must do. 21 But you should select from all the people able men, God-fearing, trustworthy, and hating dishonest profit. Place them over the people as commanders of thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens. 22 They should judge the people at all times. Then they can bring you every major case but judge every minor case themselves. In this way you will lighten your load, and they will bear it with you. 23 If you do this, and God so directs you, you will be able to endure, and also all these people will be able to go home satisfied." 24 Moses listened to his father-in-law and did everything he said. 25 So Moses chose able men from all Israel and made them leaders over the people as commanders of thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens. 26 They judged the people at all times; they would bring the hard cases to Moses, but they would judge every minor case themselves. That's the Word of the Lord. What the Dissertation Found Now let's dig into what's happening here. In my dissertation I worked through this passage carefully, and I leaned on a number of scholars along the way. The first thing to notice is that the administrative structure Jethro advised was neutral — neither good nor evil in itself. Structure is not the issue. The people who occupy the positions determine the direction of the organization. And notice how those men were chosen: for character and ability. White, writing in 2016, reasons that natural reason is compatible with revelation. Jethro was an outsider who simply noted that Moses could not sustain what he was doing. He didn't need a vision from heaven. He needed eyes. Wright, in 2021, points out that Jethro's proposal actually reinforces Moses's mediatorial role — representing the people before God while teaching God's decrees — and it reduces the burden by a program of delegation that, in Wright's words, "makes obvious sense (and has been followed in principle by wise leaders everywhere)." Then there's character. Exodus 18 offers one of the earliest biblical insights into the qualities to look for in a leader. Jethro emphasized character. The men must be capable — men of worth, noble character, moral worth. Trustworthy — men of truth. Of impeccable integrity. They would fear God, be trustworthy, and hate dishonest gain. Character, not heredity, determined who would be a judge. That's worth sitting with. Stuart, in 2006, notes that Jethro saw this could not go on indefinitely. Nothing was wrong with Moses serving as a judge; it was an obligation of his leadership. But he had overcommitted his time. Mackay, in 2018, draws a contrast. In the military encounter with the Amalekites, Moses gave Joshua command of the fighting men. Here, Moses was trying to cope with virtually everything on his own. Janzen, in 1997, makes a point I love. Jethro did not challenge Moses's role as mediator. He offered his wisdom and explained the benefits to Moses and to the people. And there was an additional benefit — developing leaders among the people. Someone could grow from judging fifty to judging hundreds with experience. Delegate as much as possible, and people gain experience as leaders. And here's a distinction that matters for our topic today. The distinction is not between secular and sacred; the Israelites would not have recognized such a division. The complex cases still required Moses's attention. Jethro wasn't dividing the holy from the unholy. He was matching the work to the worker. Alexander, in 2017, observes that Moses responds willingly and appoints officials with authority to judge at different levels. And then he writes this: "The example of Moses' delegating authority to others is a fitting reminder that within church life and society at large we need to share tasks so that no single individual is unduly burdened. Those in positions of leadership should be prepared to entrust others with appropriate and meaningful responsibilities." Moses was humble enough to realize he could not do the work alone. Even those placed in authority by God should be open to the advice of others — and Jethro, an outsider, showed compassionate concern for the well-being of the people. Garrett, in 2014, is blunt about why we resist this. He says, "Failure to delegate comes from a false sense of self-importance (the idea that if I don't do it, then it will never get done or will not be done properly)... No person is indispensable, and neither the person himself nor the organization should think of any one in that manner." A leader who believes he is indispensable may learn the hard lesson from the Lord. By delegating, a leader frees himself to spend time seeking the Lord and looking to the future. Garrett also notes that in the ancient world leadership was direct and personal — kings led armies in person. And much of Moses's prior leadership experience was overseeing sheep. You cannot delegate to sheep. One more thing worth holding onto: leaders should not let organizational structure keep them from direct interaction with their followers. And the leadership structure established in Exodus 18 would be followed for generations. Modern hierarchical leadership descends from this chapter. What Passing the Mantle Adds So how does all of this show up in the book? In Passing the Mantle, I examine four didactic pairs: Moses–Joshua, Elijah–Elisha, Jesus–the Disciples, and Paul–Timothy and Titus. Moses–Joshua provides the clearest examples of succession planning through intentional leadership development. Moses and Joshua led Israel for sixty-five years. Here's a shift worth noticing. In the Old Testament, God directed who would be appointed as successor. In the New Testament, the leader selected a group of potential successors. Then there's wise counsel. Leaders seek it. Moses listened to his father-in-law. Joshua was told to seek wise counsel from Eleazar. The disciples asked Jesus to explain the parables. Paul confirmed with the apostles that what he taught was correct. There's the importance of building a team. Jethro told Moses his methods would wear out both him and the people. So Moses built a team of judges, trained a team of priests, and had Joshua serve as his assistant. Elijah thought he was alone, but God had seven thousand who had not bowed the knee to Baal. Jesus called twelve; when he sent them out they went in pairs, not alone. Paul consistently worked in a team. There's delegation. Moses delegated judging to capable men. Elijah delegated anointing kings to Elisha. Elisha even delegated to Gehazi. Jesus delegated ministry to the disciples. Paul sent Timothy and Titus to the churches. And there's this principle: character development of the successor equals or exceeds the competencies required for the position. The leader mentored the successor; the successor spent a great deal of time with the leader, observing and asking questions. One last piece from the book. Joshua would not be the sole leader of Israel. Eleazar the high priest assisted him in distributing the Promised Land — and Eleazar is even mentioned before Joshua in the distribution, in Joshua 14:1, 17:4, 19:51, and 21:1. Moses, through Jethro's counsel, had established a hierarchy of leaders that Joshua would work through during the conquest. That's the through line. What Jethro suggested in Exodus 18 was still shaping Israel's leadership generations later. Lessons Learned Let me give you six lessons from this episode. 1. Sometimes the best advice comes from outside. Jethro was a Midianite. He wasn't in the chain of command. He wasn't an elder in Israel. He was a father-in-law with eyes and a heart. And God used him. Don't assume the counsel you need will come from inside your own house. 2. The practice may come from business, but it is applicable to your organization or ministry. Delegation, structure, leader development, succession planning — none of these belong to the marketplace. They're neutral. It's the people who fill the positions who determine the direction. A good practice doesn't become unholy because a business used it first. 3. The suggestion may come from a fellow Christian outside your organization. Sometimes the person who can see your situation most clearly is a believer who isn't on your payroll and isn't in your reporting line. They have no turf to protect. Let them speak. 4. Wise leaders are humble and always open to suggestions. Moses could have pulled rank. He had stood before Pharaoh. He had parted the sea. Instead, "Moses listened to his father-in-law and did everything he said." Alexander reminds us that even those placed in authority by God should be open to the advice of others. 5. Character matters more than credentials when leading people. Notice the character requirements. Capable. God-fearing. Trustworthy. Hating dishonest profit. Credentials and competencies are important, but they should never replace character. Look for character first, then train the competency. 6. Delegate. I will say it again — delegate. I will say it again — delegate. Garrett's warning is real: the leader who thinks he's indispensable is headed for a hard lesson. Build the team. Share the load. And watch people grow from judging fifty to judging hundreds. PAUSE Closing and a Look Ahead "But it's not Christian." I hope you see it now. A neutral structure placed in a Christian environment, a good practice examined through the lens of Scripture, counsel received from an outsider who cared about the people of God — this is not compromise. This is wisdom. Moses took the advice. He selected able men, God-fearing, trustworthy, hating dishonest profit. He set them over thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens. The load got lighter, the people got leaders, and Moses got to keep doing what only Moses could do. But that raises a question, doesn't it? What became of Joshua after he succeeded Moses? Joshua had been Moses's assistant for years. He'd been on the mountain. He'd commanded the fighting men against Amalek. He'd watched Moses take Jethro's counsel and build something that outlasted the man who built it. So next time, we'll walk through Joshua's life and ministry — the whole arc of it. We'll recap the lessons he learned during his time with Moses, and what he did with them once the mantle was on his shoulders. You won't want to miss it. Until then, if you want to go deeper, visit the podcast website for show notes, episode archives, and ways to get in touch. Keep examining. Keep delegating. Keep passing the mantle. God bless you.

Other Episodes

Episode 2

September 25, 2026 • 00:21:28
Episode Cover

Crisis Management or Succession Planning

Why do so many organizations scramble to find a new leader only after someone leaves? In Episode 2 of Passing the Mantle, Peter Frost...

Listen

Episode 5

October 30, 2026 • 00:22:20
Episode Cover

Episode 5 - The Lone Dissenter

What does it mean to stand by your convictions when everyone around you disagrees? In this episode of Passing the Mantle, Peter Frost reflects...

Listen

Episode 6

November 06, 2026 • 00:23:24
Episode Cover

Episode 6 - When It's Time To Go

In Episode 6, "When It's Time to Go," we ask the question every leader eventually faces: when — and how — do you transition...

Listen